Did you like Heretic?
One tap. It tunes your For You and tells others who loved it what to try next.
Two young missionaries are forced to prove their faith when they knock on the wrong door and are greeted by a diabolical Mr. Reed, becoming ensnared in his deadly game of cat-and-mouse.
If you liked Heretic, the community suggests
Ranked by community votes — AI and similarity picks fill in while votes are few.
No votes here yet — be the first to rank this list
At 10 votes this becomes a true community ranking. Seen any of these? Tap “Closest” on the one that felt most like it.
- 1Obsession2026MovieSimilar genres
- 2Deep Water2026MovieSimilar genres
- 3Passenger2026MovieSimilar genres
- 4Hungry2026MovieSimilar genres
Something else felt closer? Suggest it — any medium.
Cast & crew
Hugh Grant
Mr. Reed
Sophie Thatcher
Sister Barnes
Chloe East
Sister Paxton
Topher Grace
Elder Kennedy
Elle Young
Prophet
Julie Lynn-Mortensen
Pedestrian
Haylie Hansen
Teenager
Elle McKinnon
Teenager
Hanna Huffman
Teenager
Anesha Bailey
Neighbor
Miguel Castillo
Neighbor
Stephanie Lavigne
Believer
Scott Beck
Director
Bryan Woods
Director